October 10, 2011 by Stacy McDonald

Chicken Pickin’

Print Friendly

In the McDonald household, “Chicken Pickin'” time is a highly valued family tradition. Basically, it’s the time when children (especially those who look like they need a “job”) are chosen to gather around the table (little children too) to “pick” chicken meat off the bones after making rich, homemade chicken stock. When it’s all finished, we bag up the shredded chicken, put the rich, golden broth in mason jars and store it all in the freezer for cooking over the next few weeks or months (depending on how much is made).

While some people these days think chicken broth comes in a can, once you taste homemade stock you’re ruined for life! You can’t find anything close to this on a grocery store shelf! Plus most commercial broths are loaded with MSG and sodium, and none are as rich and tasty as homemade!

Homemade Chicken Stock

Start with two whole 4-5 lb. Chickens, cut up with the bones exposed. Or, you can use chicken backs, wings, legs, thighs, necks, or gizzards. You can ask your butcher for a good price on cheaper cuts and he may even chop it all up for you. Cutting up the bones helps the marrow to escape into your broth.

  • 6 quarts of water
  • A small handful of fresh garlic cloves, coarsely chopped
  • A bundle of celery with leaves, coarsely chopped
  • 2 whole yellow onions, coarsely chopped
  • A hand full of coarsely chopped carrots
  • 1 C. fresh chopped parsley
  • 4 bay leafs
  • 1 T. dried thyme (or fresh)
  • A few teaspoons of dried oregano, basil, rosemary or other favorite herbs (or fresh)
  • Fresh ginger (optional, but very good if you’re making broth for someone who is ill)
  • Sea salt
  • Fresh ground Pepper
  • 2 T. Juice from fresh lemon or lime or Raw apple cider vinegar

Place everything in a large stock pot and bring to a rolling boil. Once it’s boiling, cover the pot and turn down the fire. Simmer on medium-low for about 2 hours, or until done. Remove chicken and let cool slightly in a large casserole dish or jelly roll pan. Allow broth to continue to simmer on low during this time. Gather any stray children who look like they need something to do and put them together at a table to “pick chicken” off the bones. Once the chicken is picked, divide it into one quart bags for later use in soups, casseroles, and other recipes.

Now, take all the bones and scraps and put them back into the broth. Simmer down to a manageable amount, and place the whole batch into a crock pot for an overnight simmer. In the morning, strain through a fine mesh strainer, dispose of bones and vegetables, pour broth into mason jars, cool, and refrigerate. Once the broth is chilled, you can easily remove the hardened fat layer from the top.* Use or freeze as desired.

The overnight simmer is optional, and the broth will still taste phenomenal without it; however, if you’ve ever had stock that is simmered this way and this long, you’ll see why we go to the extra trouble. Also, the longer it simmers, the more marrow is removed from the bone and the healthier and richer the broth is. The more “gelatinous” the broth, the more marrow it contains.

Chicken broth is not only good for your favorite recipes, it’s fantastic for anyone recuperating from an illness. It’s warm, easy to digest, delicious, and filled with a ton of immune boosting herbs and spices. This stock enhances your immune system and provides you with easy to assimilate minerals. The marrow inside the bones contains nutrients that feed your bone marrow. When your bone marrow is nourished, you create healthier immune cells and can better fight off colds and other viruses.

*Since my chickens are organic, I sometimes save the fat separately and use for making roux for gumbo and creoles. Other times, I leave it in for a richer broth.

Tips for Healing:

If you have just had a baby, supplement your meals by drinking two cups of this rich broth each day for several months. If you are recovering from an illness, surgery, trauma, or fatigue good rich marrow-filled broth is an excellent meal choice while you recuperate.

The more fresh garlic the better!

Add a Tablespoon of an acidic ingredient to your stock (wine; lemon or lime juice; or raw apple cider vinegar), it helps to leech the minerals from the bones.

Similar Posts:

10 Responses to “Chicken Pickin’”

  1. Kris says:

    I love a good homemade broth. I’ve frozen it before but have been thinking of canning a few jars. Have you ever tried canning broth?

  2. Stacy McDonald says:

    No. I always freeze mine. I still use mason jars though.

  3. This is EXACTLY how we make broth! Although typically I’m in charge of “de-boning” the chicken. LOL Now I want chicken and rice soup…

  4. Thanks for sharing! We’ve been making our own broth with our home grown chickens and store it in the freezer, too. I was unaware of the wisdom of using broth for recuperating as you suggested and will have to keep that suggestion in mind! Many blessings, ~Lisa

  5. We love it too. How fun to find someone who does it just like we do. I’ll have to involve others with the pickin’ part. Thanks for sharing.

  6. Erica says:

    I love this, especially the addition of the extra herbs. I also recently read about and then tried reusing the bones for another go around of broth. Here’s the link, in case anyone else is interested:


    I also like your encouragement for how healthy the broth is. Thanks, Stacy!


  7. We do this ritual here in our home, too!! I am thankful you are teaching about broth and the value it brings to our broth-based dishes! Stacy, I want to thank you and the church family for making us feel so welcome and at home! Your daughters were delightful to ‘do business with’. I pray you are feeling much better very soon! I am coming down with a head cold just this morning myself, so I will be taking my elderberry tincture a lot today :) May the Lord bless you, and grace and peace to you.

  8. Heather Newcomb says:

    A cold has hit our household and I am not much of a cook. I’m about to go out and buy the stuff to make this and then try to make us a batch of chicken noodle soup. Thanks for being a teacher to us mothers who didn’t learn when we were young. I’m pregnant with my 5th baby and making my first batch of chicken broth! Yikes! Better late than never right? And my children will be learning with me, sick and all! lol

  9. Susan C. says:

    I have actually read that the fat in the broth has some of the healthiest benefits of all of it! This goes completely against how I was raised (in the midst of the low-fat/fat-free craze) but apparently it has some vital nutrients, immune-boosting and illness-fighting properties that you don’t want to just throw away. So, I’ve been just leaving the fat right in! Thanks for a great recipe–yours is a little different from mine, and I hadn’t thought about adding fresh ginger! Awesome! :)

  10. Stacy McDonald says:

    You are right, Susan! Since my chickens are organic, I sometimes save the fat separately and use for making roux for gumbo and creoles. Other times, I leave it in for a richer broth.

    I would not recommend eating the fat from non-organic chickens.

Leave a Reply

Please note: Comment moderation is currently enabled so there will be a delay between when you post your comment and when it shows up. Patience is a virtue; there is no need to re-submit your comment.